Protection Metals on Monitor to Construct Uncommon Earth Mine

Rick Mills of Forward of the Herd gives an outline of the ups and downs within the uncommon earths market and discusses one firm that he believes has all the weather in place for a “profitable, small-scale uncommon earth operation.”

Those that have labored within the enterprise so long as I’ve will simply bear in mind the uncommon earth mania of 2008–11. For about three years following China’s export restrictions on uncommon earth parts, which hiked the costs of REEs to report highs, the junior useful resource market was awash with new uncommon earth explorers.

These tiny firms fanned out throughout (principally) Canada, the U.S. and Australia looking for the subsequent uncommon earths motherlode that will break the world’s dependence on China, which then and now has a monopoly—the nation both mines or processes one thing like 95% of the 17 uncommon earth parts (REEs) and turns them into oxides, then continues the method of constructing high-purity metals, alloys and powders which can be utilized in every part from cell telephones, flat-screen TVs, everlasting magnets and lasers, to wind generators, nuclear reactors and missile steering programs. Click on right here for a extra complete listing.

They principally failed. Not a type of extremely touted junior held uncommon earth deposits exterior China has been become a mine. The hype dissipated and useful resource traders moved on to different metals.

Arguably although, the significance of uncommon earth parts has by no means gone away; in reality they’re extra essential than ever, as commerce tensions between the U.S. and China and the markets for REEs develop—similar to for neodymium, praseodymium and dysprosium utilized in everlasting magnets positioned in electrical autos.

For extra learn our Uncommon earths in cross-hairs of recent arms race.

This text will look again on the uncommon earth mania, describe why none of those firms have made it previous the feasibility stage, and current a roadmap for the way to construct a uncommon earths mine, one step at a time, that’s each possible and cost-effective.

Uncommon earth mania

In the present day, the one vital non-Chinese language corporations at present producing uncommon earth parts are Molycorp, whose Mountain Move mine in California mines the REEs and ships them to China for processing, and Lynas, whose Mt. Weld mine in Western Australia produces a focus that’s processed in Malaysia. A couple of different international locations produce a handful, tonnage-wise, of REEs however they’re very small in comparison with China—simply 1,600 to three,000 tonnes yearly in comparison with China’s 105,000 tonnes.

For a time although, uncommon earths had been on the lips of each mining funding home and useful resource junior. To not have a uncommon earths play meant lacking out on the celebration. The chart beneath courtesy of Avista Group exhibits the bubble inflating then the pop. For example, dysprosium costs rocketed from $118 a kilogram in 2008 to an insane $2,262/kg in 2011. Europium ran up from round $600/kg in 2010 to $three,000/kg the next 12 months.

Whereas the spike in uncommon earths costs was good for Molycorp and all of the exploration firms that sprang up looking for them, patrons of merchandise constituted of uncommon earths balked and pressured governments to do one thing about it. The U.S., European Union and Japan introduced a case to the World Commerce Group to attempt to settle the dispute and get China to elevate the restrictions.

In 2015 it did, leading to a torrent of Chinese language uncommon earth exports into the market and the inevitable collapse in costs. The transfer caught Molycorp off-guard. The corporate had simply spent over a billion on one other improve at Mountain Move however inside months, Molycorp fell deeply in debt and went bankrupt.

A lot of the uncommon earth juniors withered and died too. For a extra detailed historical past learn our How the US misplaced the plot on uncommon earths.

Separation anxiousness

Mining uncommon earth parts is pretty easy: if discovered shut sufficient to floor they are often scooped up in open pits, crushed and gravity-separated from the host minerals, however separating and extracting a single REE takes an excessive amount of time, effort and experience.

The ore is floor utilizing crushers and rotating grinding mills, magnetic separation (bastnasite and monazite are extremely magnetic, they are often separated from non-magnetic impurities within the ore by means of repeated electromagnetic separation) and flotation provides you the bottom worth sellable product within the uncommon earth provide chain—the concentrated ore. The milling tools, together with crushers; grinding mills; flotation units; and magnetic, gravity, and electrostatic separators, all need to be configured in a means that fits the kind of ore being mined—no two ores reply the identical means.

The foremost worth in REE processing lies within the manufacturing of high-purity uncommon earth oxides (REOs) and metals—but it surely is not simple. A REE refinery makes use of ion change and/or multi-stage solvent extraction know-how to separate and purify the REEs. Solvent-extraction processes contain re-immersing processed ore into completely different chemical options so as to separate particular person parts. The weather are so shut to one another when it comes to atomic weight that every of those processes entails a number of phases to finish the separation course of. In some instances it requires a number of hundred tanks of various options to separate one uncommon earth component. Heavy uncommon earth parts are the toughest, most time-consuming to separate.

The composition of REOs may range drastically; they’ll and sometimes are designed to fulfill the specs laid out by the end-product customers. An REO that fits one producer’s wants might not swimsuit one other’s.

For extra on mining and processing REEs, learn our Mine to Magnet.

Doing it mistaken

The challenges of manufacturing something extra then a uncommon earth focus has all the time been a number of fold for junior useful resource firms—sophisticated mineralogy means sophisticated costly metallurgy, an absence of infrastructure and an absence of technical information of the extraction course of.

The disbursement of the REEs in a typical deposit will not be uniform and they’re typically contained in several ores—as excessive as 5. The extra sophisticated the minerology the extra sophisticated, costly and time consuming metallurgy can be. An absence of infrastructure doubles down in your issues. This contains simply accessible energy, water, NG, roads and railways. Many uncommon earth properties are removed from any infrastructure, minimizing the prospect of development.

Much more difficult is creating a hydrometallurgical plant to provide the separate excessive purity uncommon earth oxides.

One of many world’s foremost REE geologists and mineralogists, Tony Mariano, says every REE deposit, assuming a positive political local weather and good logistics, will want sure circumstances current:

Favorable mineralogy and lanthanide distribution

Needed grade and tonnage

Mining and mineral processing at low prices
Profitable chemical cracking of the person lanthanides for his or her isolation and eventual restoration

Low values of thorium, uranium and different deleterious impurities

Minimal environmental affect

Dudley Kingsnorth of Industrial Minerals Firm of Australia outlines the mandatory steps to take a REE deposit all the best way to manufacturing:

Show useful resource: grade, distribution and perceive mineralogy

Outline course of and bench scale—every ore-body is exclusive. Due to this uniqueness a brand new separation course of must be developed for every particular person deposit

Conduct pre-feasibility research

Exhibit technical and industrial viability of the method

Receive environmental approval

Publish Letters of Intent—advertising and marketing is buyer particular. The principle value-added from uncommon earths will not be within the mining and extraction, so it’s essential to both develop your personal provide chain or acquire entry to an present provide chain

Full a bankable feasibility research

Impact development and start-up

There are vital limitations to entry into the uncommon earths market:

Creating a uncommon earth mine and processing plant is capital intensive. Capability prices are excessive—US$30,000+ per tonne of annual separated capability versus lower than US$3500 for an open pit mine within the U.S. historical past exhibits that the event time may be very lengthy at 10-15 years

Operational experience on mining, cracking and separating may be very restricted exterior of China

Main mining firms and establishments are delay by excessive capex investments in such a tightly centered market. This leaves juniors with potential growth points

Again in 2008–11, all these challenges did not dissuade tons of of juniors, whose cubicles lined the aisles of PDAC, from grabbing the chance to money in on uncommon earth mania. Till costs crashed in 2012 and the hype was over. A couple of are nonetheless round, however most perished within the chilly winter of investor disenchantment that descended on the uncommon earths sector post-2012. The phrase “over-promised and under-delivered” involves thoughts.

The technique of most of those firms went one thing like this: establish a uncommon earth deposit, then hone in on probably the most invaluable REEs—sometimes heavy uncommon earth parts like dysprosium, europium, terbium, gadolinium, and so forth.—which on the time had been commanding record-high costs.

The plan was to mine probably the most profitable uncommon earths, produce a focus, after which construct a refinery, at nice expense, for changing the uncommon earth focus into particular person 99.5% oxides, powders, metals and alloys for every desired REE on the market to end-users.

The issue was that the majority of those firms both did not perceive the sophisticated course of concerned in mining/ processing uncommon earths, or did know, and hid the reality from traders.

A few examples—no names can be talked about.

The uncommon earths deposit is positioned in a distant area with no infrastructure. In accordance with a prefeasibility research, the open-pit operation would goal the highest-grade REE mineralization. The mission has a capex (capital expenditures) finances of $2.6 billion, together with a hydrometallurgical facility that will produce 4 merchandise: one heavy and one gentle REE focus, one oxide and one by-product mineral. The ore can be crushed on the mine web site, trucked to a port, after which shipped alongside a canal to the hydro-met facility for additional processing. Annual revenues would common north of a billion .

One other mission can also be on the center of nowhere with no cities, roads or energy close by. Complete capex together with a mine, mill and hydrometallurgical advanced is simply over $500 million. Ore from the underground mine can be mined and processed right into a focus, then barged roughly 200 kilometers to the uncommon earths refinery, the place there may be vitality and transportation infrastructure.

Each of those tasks don’t have any infrastructure, exorbitant capex that will scare off any institutional investor, and sophisticated mine plans, each when it comes to logistics and processing. We might’ve chosen many different ill-fated examples.

Even when a junior miner was in a position to produce an oxide, that is not the tip of the highway. From an preliminary 98% purity, the oxide have to be additional refined to 99.5% purity required by most end-users. The fee to extend the purity to 99.5%, and the technical know-how/ operational experience, is properly past the capabilities of virtually each junior miner for the a number of causes listed above.

Only a few REE miners will ever receives a commission for producing a 98% oxide not to mention a 99.5% pure oxide.

It is extra doubtless that the majority REE juniors will find yourself promoting a blended uncommon earth focus corresponding to what a junior copper miner would promote.

Others additional up the REE value-added provide chain (i.e., end-users who’ve a proprietary course of) will flip the focus into uncommon earth oxides and proceed the method of constructing the high-purity metals, alloys and powders.

Doing it proper

Luckily there may be a better technique to mine uncommon earths with out entering into the inordinately excessive capital expenditures and processing complexity. The reply? Maintain it easy and small, take what mom nature simply provides you.

At Forward of the Herd we have recognized a mission in northern British Columbia that has all the weather in place for a profitable, small-scale uncommon earth operation: Protection Metals Corp.’s (DEFN:TSX.V; DFMTF:OTCQB) Wicheeda Challenge.

Positioned near a serious inhabitants heart, Prince George, Wicheeda has no uranium, low thorium values, all the mandatory infrastructure, the deposit has easy mineralogy, and the metallurgy has already been demonstrated by means of bench-scale testing.

Sufficient historic drilling has been carried out to compile an historic non-43-101 compliant useful resource estimate of 11.2 million tonnes grading 1.95% Mild Uncommon Earth Parts at a 1% cut-off (LREE = Ce + La + Nd).

A 2009 research was designed to find the benefit of constructing a uncommon earth focus from a composite rock pattern taken from Wicheeda carbonatite, primarily based on three assay samples.

Bench-scale testing yielded extra doubtlessly recoverable uncommon earth parts than the useful resource estimate’s present REEs (lanthanum, cerium, neodymium and samarium) similar to dysprosium, europium and praseodymium.

The research writer, Tony Mariano cited above, famous he is solely seen a high-grade REE focus just like the Wicheeda composite in China, the middle of world uncommon earths processing.

Bench-scale flotation and hydrometallurgical testwork was carried out on Wicheeda drill cores at a SGS Lakefield lab throughout 2010–11. SGS efficiently developed a flotation circulation sheet that recovered 83% of the uncommon earth oxide (REO) and produced a focus grading 42% REO.

Subsequent hydrometallurgical testing in 2012 on a two-kilogram pattern of the focus grading 39.7% TREO (whole REO) produced an upgraded and purified precipitate that contained 71% TREO by means of a technique of pre-leaching and roasting.

For extra learn our Protection Metals has sights set on uncommon earths, uranium.

This is not simply one other uncommon earths story pump, like dozens of others advised throughout uncommon earth mania. This mission differs considerably from others which have tried, and failed, earlier than it. Here is how:

Infrastructure in place. At 80 km northwest of Prince George, Wicheeda is not distant. The deposit is located alongside a serious forestry service highway that’s related to Freeway 97, the principle artery working by means of northern BC. Prince George has many industries at present utilizing chemical substances similar to caustic soda and hydrochloric acid, and by-products of operations vary from white/black liquor to lime and others. There’s a skilled workforce already very aware of the delivery/receiving, use of, and correct disposal of chemical substances, being dwelling to a methanex plant and three pulp mills.

A deliberate 200-tonne-per-day pilot plant on a dormant sawmill web site at Bear Lake is a brief 40-minute drive north of Prince George on Hwy 97. A CN rail line runs previous the previous sawmill web site and there’s a siding working into the positioning. The Bear Lake web site has ample energy, water, a railway siding and a close-by pure fuel pipeline—all the weather wanted for uncommon earth processing and delivery.

Uncomplicated mining. The uncommon earth minerals bastnasite and monazite, containing the REEs, are disseminated pretty uniformly all through the property. Mining can be an open-pit situation, which is mainly simply an earth-moving operation. The uncooked ore can be run by means of a magnetic separator—bastnasite and monazite are magnetic—with the ensuing early-stage focus trucked to DEFN’s pilot plant in Bear lake for additional processing.

Work with Mom Nature. Not like different uncommon earth juniors, Protection Metals is not promising the moon and delivering an asteroid. The corporate’s plan is to make use of no matter parts are within the uncommon earth minerals to provide a blended uncommon earth focus that will be bought, doubtless on long-term contracts, to end-users.

Scale up slowly. Manufacturing, below a BC Small Mine Allow, would steadily be scaled up, from a 30-tonne bulk pattern to a 200-tonne per day pilot plant that proves the flexibility to provide a blended uncommon earth focus for industrial manufacturing. Protection Metals might additionally use its scaled-up processing plant to “contract course of” different firms’ uncommon earths right into a focus. There are three phases to the ramp-up: Step 1: Bulk pattern metallurgical testing/ re-assaying the pulps. Protection Metals has despatched a 30-tonne bulk pattern from the deposit to SGS Canada’s Lakefield, Ont. metallurgical facility. “Constructing on the profitable bench scale flotation testwork performed in 2012 by SGS on a 100 kg composite pattern of Wicheeda drill core, the objective of the Section 1A testwork is to develop a strong circulation sheet for producing high-grade REE flotation concentrates from a 200-kg pattern of the 30-tonne Wicheeda REE deposit bulk pattern. It’s anticipated that 20 kg of REE focus can be produced by Section 1A,” stated Chris Graf, DEFN’s technical advisor.

After the 20-kg pattern of flotation focus has been produced, hydrometallugical testwork on the pattern is anticipated to begin on the finish of Could, to provide a purified, blended REE focus and supply knowledge for the design of a 200 tonne-per-day pilot plant at Bear Lake.

Step 2: Pilot plant. The focus pilot plant will take all the 30-tonne Wicheeda Lake bulk pattern and course of it, with the objective of demonstrating that the Section 1 A flowsheet is able to producing a high-grade REE focus at an industrial scale.

Step three: Hydrometallurgical take a look at plant. The final step, and Protection Metals’ final objective, is to construct a hydrometallurgical plant at Bear Lake that will convert the uncommon earth focus into particular person uncommon earth oxides, on the market to particular end-users. It is anticipated that the Section 2 pilot plant metallurgical testwork will produce about three tonnes of REE focus that may be examined by a Section three hydrometallurgical pilot plant.

Click on on the Feb 25 operational replace for extra particulars

As soon as the plant enters industrial manufacturing, clients might embody army protection contractors, contemplating the excessive focus of metals used for protection functions, and firms within the magnet manufacturing sector, which require combos of neodymium, praseodymium and dysprosium or samarium and cobalt. Just like the focus processing plant plant, the hydro-met plant might additionally do “contract processing” of different REEs from firms that ship their uncommon earth concentrates, by rail, on to DEFN’s Bear Lake facility.


Generally much less is extra, particularly when “extra” comes at nice expense and investor threat. Protection Metals has provide you with a really manageable plan to cost-effectively put an especially potential uncommon earths deposit into manufacturing.

Not like many juniors earlier than it, the plan would not contain a billion-dollar capex that features a mine, mill and processing plant. As an alternative, DEFN is piggy-backing on earlier bench-scale testing to slowly show the metallurgy after which scale up—first creating a circulation sheet from a 200-kg pattern, to get 20kg of REE focus. Then a pilot plant to check whether or not the unique 30-tonne bulk pattern can produce a focus at industrial scale. And at last, a hydrometallurgical take a look at plant that may produce three tonnes of REE focus—sufficient for industrial use.

Every step that’s efficiently accomplished will present extra confidence for traders, and additional de-risk the mission. If all these steps are accomplished, we see there being no scarcity of shoppers wanting to buy DEFN’s high-purity REE focus. At this stage we might additionally see Protection Metals as a high-priority takeout candidate by a magnet producer, for instance, desirous to lock up a dependable provide of uncommon earth focus, exterior of China.

I am wanting ahead to the profitable completion of Section 1A, a 20-kg focus.

Richard (Rick) Mills

Forward of the Herd Twitter

Forward of the Herd now on FaceBook

Richard (Rick) Mills,, lives on a 160-acre farm in northern British Columbia. Richard’s articles have been revealed on over 400 web sites, together with: WallStreetJournal, USAToday, NationalPost, Lewrockwell, MontrealGazette, VancouverSun, CBSnews, HuffingtonPost, Beforeitsnews, Londonthenews, Wealthwire, CalgaryHerald, Forbes, Dallasnews, SGTreport, Vantagewire, Indiatimes, Ninemsn, Ibtimes, Businessweek, HongKongHerald, Moneytalks, SeekingAlpha, BusinessInsider,, and the Affiliation of Mining Analysts.


1) Rick Mills: I, or members of my speedy family or household, personal shares of the next firms talked about on this article: Protection Metals. I personally am, or members of my speedy family or household are, paid by the next firms talked about on this article: None. My firm at present has a monetary relationship with the next firms talked about on this article: Protection Metals is an advertiser on Forward of the Herd. I made up my mind which firms can be included on this article primarily based on my analysis and understanding of the sector. Further disclosures/disclaimer beneath.
2) The next firms talked about on this article are sponsors of Streetwise Experiences: Protection Metals. Click on right here for essential disclosures about sponsor charges.
three) Feedback and opinions expressed are these of the precise consultants and never of Streetwise Experiences or its officers. The writer is wholly chargeable for the validity of the statements. The writer was not paid by Streetwise Experiences for this text. Streetwise Experiences was not paid by the writer to publish or syndicate this text. The data supplied above is for informational functions solely and isn’t a suggestion to purchase or promote any safety. Streetwise Experiences requires contributing authors to reveal any shareholdings in, or financial relationships with, firms that they write about. Streetwise Experiences depends upon the authors to precisely present this info and Streetwise Experiences has no technique of verifying its accuracy.
four) The article doesn’t represent funding recommendation. Every reader is inspired to seek the advice of along with his or her particular person monetary skilled and any motion a reader takes on account of info introduced right here is his or her personal accountability. By opening this web page, every reader accepts and agrees to Streetwise Experiences’ phrases of use and full authorized disclaimer. This text will not be a solicitation for funding. Streetwise Experiences doesn’t render common or particular funding recommendation and the knowledge on Streetwise Experiences shouldn’t be thought of a suggestion to purchase or promote any safety. Streetwise Experiences doesn’t endorse or suggest the enterprise, merchandise, providers or securities of any firm talked about on Streetwise Experiences.
5) Once in a while, Streetwise Experiences LLC and its administrators, officers, staff or members of their households, in addition to individuals interviewed for articles and interviews on the positioning, might have a protracted or brief place in securities talked about. Administrators, officers, staff or members of their speedy households are prohibited from making purchases and/or gross sales of these securities within the open market or in any other case from the time of the interview or the choice to write down an article till three enterprise days after the publication of the interview or article. The foregoing prohibition doesn’t apply to articles that in substance solely restate beforehand revealed firm releases. As of the date of this interview, officers and/or staff of Streetwise Experiences LLC (together with members of their family) personal securities of Protection Metals, an organization talked about on this article.

Photographs supplied by the writer.

Forward of the Herd Authorized Discover / Disclaimer

This doc will not be and shouldn’t be construed as a suggestion to promote or the solicitation of a suggestion to buy or subscribe for any funding. Richard Mills has primarily based this doc on info obtained from sources he believes to be dependable however which has not been independently verified. Richard Mills makes no assure, illustration or guarantee and accepts no accountability or legal responsibility as to its accuracy or completeness. Expressions of opinion are these of Richard Mills solely and are topic to alter with out discover. Richard Mills assumes no guarantee, legal responsibility or assure for the present relevance, correctness or completeness of any info supplied inside this Report and won’t be held accountable for the consequence of reliance upon any opinion or assertion contained herein or any omission. Moreover, I, Richard Mills, assume no legal responsibility for any direct or oblique loss or injury or, specifically, for misplaced revenue, which you will incur on account of the use and existence of the knowledge supplied inside this Report.

Protection Metals (TSX-V:DEFN) is an advertiser on Richard’s web site Richard owns shares of DEFN.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *